Fill This Form To Receive Instant Help

Help in Homework

Comparative Essay Frederick Douglass and Harriet Jacobs

Categories: Literature

  • Words: 2544

Published: Jun 28, 2024

This comparative essay will explore how the events in Life of a Slave Girl and Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass, an enslaved American, speak to one another or fit together. Harriet Jacobs was the author of Life of an enslaved person Girl, and the Narrative of the Life of Frederick Doug lass was written by himself. This paper will compare and contrast the occurrences described in those two works. The significance of the overlap, in addition to specific variances and parallels in the texts, will also be investigated in this study. Both Frederick Douglass and Harriet Jacobs published compelling accounts of their experiences living as slaves in the United States. Like many other slaves, both had the same goal of achieving freedom, and to get there, they had to overcome many similar challenges but were unique in their ways (Gottesman et al., 1980). Douglass was a male, and Jacobs was a woman who significantly impacted how they were bound during their time as slaves, even though both faced a great deal of suffering while working toward achieving their freedom. The life experiences of Jacobs, an enslaved woman, were very different from those of Douglass, an enslaved male (Gottesman et al., 1980). These differences manifested themselves in a variety of various ways.

One of the significant facts connecting both works is that they are all told from the perspective of slaves throughout their time in the United States, making them comparable. Both volumes shed insight on the treatment of slaves and the activities they participated in daily (Gottesman et al., 1980). They are complementary to one another because they provide an in-depth explanation of slavery from the perspectives of both a male and a woman simultaneously. Incidents in the "Life of a Slave Girl" was written by a woman born into slavery, while Narrative of the "Life of Frederick Douglass" was written by a man born free but later sold into slavery. Both authors were African Americans. In addition, they both emphasize the significance of knowledge as an instrument for achieving control and establishing one's autonomy.

Moreover, the other analogy that establishes the context for examining these two works is that both of these works have certain things in common. Still, there are also some crucial differences between them. For example, Douglass was a guy whose gender influenced how he experienced slavery. On the other hand, Jacobs was a female, and her gender influenced how she experienced slavery (Gottesman et al., 1980). In addition, Frederick Douglass was born a free man but was later forced to work as a slave, whereas Jacobs was born into slavery.

These numerous perspectives offer a complete picture of the myriad of experiences that slaves in the United States went through throughout their time there.

Incidents in the "Life of a Slave Girl" and "The Life of Frederick Douglass" overlap and are significant because they provide a more comprehensive depiction of the myriad ways slaves lived in the United States (Gottesman et al., 1980). These perspectives offer an insightful look into the minds of slaves seeking to make sense of the situations in which they found themselves. The similarities and differences between the two books contribute to creating a more nuanced understanding of slavery. Consider, for example, the various ways in which the experiences of Douglass and Jacobs were influenced by their respective genders. In addition, Frederick Douglass was born a free man but was later forced to work as a slave, whereas Jacobs was born into slavery. The multitude of perspectives presented here paints a complete picture of the myriad of situations slaves in the United States went through. A few instances in "The Life of Frederick Douglass" and "The Life of a Slave Girl" are similar to one another (Gottesman et al., 1980). For instance, according to Gottesman et al. (1980), the experience of being a slave is depicted in both works in a manner that is both in-depth and horrific to the reader. Both offer a one-of-a-kind peek inside the mind of a slave seeking to make sense of the circumstances in which they find themselves. However, there have been some substantial alterations made (Gottesman et al., 1980). For example, Douglass was male, and his gender influenced how he experienced slavery (Gottesman et al., 1980). On the other hand, Jacobs was a female, and her gender influenced how she experienced slavery. In addition, Frederick Douglass was born a free man but was later forced to work as a slave, whereas Jacobs was born into slavery. These diverse perspectives help create a complete understanding of the myriad of situations slaves in the United States went through.

The other significant fact that connects both works is that these "Incidents" are first-person narratives that describe the experience of slavery in the United States. Both of these works provide a comprehensive and upsetting analysis of the facts of daily slavery, as well as a one­ of-a-kind, look into the mind of a slave who is struggling to make sense of the circumstances in which they find themselves. These works have certain things in common but also some crucial differences (Gottesman et al., 1980).

In their first-person accounts of the experience of slavery in the United States, both authors use a variety of rhetorical and literary approaches to highlight the harsh reality of life as a slave. Both authors' narratives are written in the first person. For instance, the experience of being a slave is depicted in both works in a manner that is both in-depth and horrific to the reader. Both off er a one-of-a-kind peek inside the mind of a slave seeking to make sense of the circumstances in which they find themselves. According to Gottesman et al. (1980), these works have certain things in common but also some crucial differences. For example, Douglass was male, and his gender influenced how he experienced slavery. On the other hand, Jacobs was a female, and her gender influenced how she experienced slavery (Gottesman et al., 1980).

Both of these accounts provide a first-person perspective on the institution of slavery in the United States. Consequently, both authors use various rhetorical and literary strategies to portray what it was like to be a slave accurately. By utilizing literary and rhetorical devices, the author provides the reader with the opportunity to obtain a new understanding of the harsh reality of life as a slave. For example, to communicate the horrible reality of life as a       slave, vivid language is utilized in both of the writings mentioned above, written in the first person (Gottesman et al., 1980). By reading first-person accounts, readers get the opportunity to experience the harsh realities of life as a slave through the eyes of someone who has lived it. In addition, the usage of particular particulars results in the painting of a realistic picture of the harsh reality of life as a slave.

These incidents brought the significance of social conceptions such as religion, politics, racism, ableism, gender, and prejudice to light. The experience of being a slave is depicted in both of these books in a way that is both detailed and horrific to the reader. For example, slave masters in both narratives are shown to use religion as a form of control over their slaves (Gottesman et al., 1980). Both books detail how enslaved people were treated unequally because of their race. Both volumes delve into how different genders were affected differently by the ordeal of slavery. For example, according to Gottesman et al. (1980), Douglass was male, and his gender influenced how he experienced slavery. On the other hand, Jacobs was a female, and her gender influenced how she experienced slavery. These perspectives give a complete picture of the myriad of experiences that slaves in the United States went through throughout their time there.

In conclusion, the relationship between men and women was a significant factor in the life of slaves. In addition to being beaten, slave women were subjected to other forms of abuse specific to their gender. In most cases, males were put to death or subjected to torturous punishments, but in addition to them, women were emotionally and verbally mistreated. Gender played a role in the dynamics of the interactions that existed between the owners and their slaves. Jacobs' testimony in her narrative demonstrates that sexual abuse was a typical occurrence between the master and the female slaves (Gottesman et al., 1980). The mental and physical violence perpetrated upon female slaves by their lords' jealous wives was in addition to the sexual abuse they were forced to endure. Slaves were forced to endure all three forms of abuse. Of course, neither of these are considered forms of mistreatment of the male slave is subjected to. Not only did the lives of male and female slaves differ in terms of their experiences, but also their perspectives did as well. Douglass believed that education was the key to achieving strength and power (Gottesman et al., 1980). Reading and writing were stepping-stones on the path to becoming a man for him. It gave him the impression that he could compete with his white peers, which instilled in him a sense of equality and, at times, even a sense of superiority (Gottesman et al., 1980). On the other hand, according to Gottesman et al. (1980), Jacobs did not have an extreme desire to improve his literacy. Jacobs drew her strength from her loved ones, particularly her family. She demonstrated the significance of preserving relationships inside one's own family. It should not come as a surprise to learn this, given the significance of relationships in most women's lives.

References

  • Gottesman, R., Holland, L. B., Kalstone, D., Murphy, F., Parker, H., & Pritchard, W. H. (1980). The Norton anthology of American literature. WW Norton & Company, Inc., New York.

Get high-quality help

img

Mike Futia

imgVerified writer
Expert in:Literature

4.2 (164 reviews)

Thanks for assigning a tutor for my writing classes. The guidance was valuable, and I would definitely recommend your services.


img +122 experts online

Learn the cost and time for your paper

- +

In addition to visual imagery, Cisneros also employs sensory imagery to enhance the reader's experience of the novel. Throughout the story

Remember! This is just a sample.

You can get your custom paper by one of our expert writers.

+122 experts online
img