Homework answers / question archive / ASCI 512 6

ASCI 512 6

Writing

Share With

---

ASCI 512 6.4 Peer Review Submission

In Module 5, you posted your Literature Review (first draft) with a bibliography to this discussion forum. Now it's time to conduct two peer reviews. 

Your job as a peer reviewer is to follow the peer review checklist below and give cogent, professional feedback. The elements that make your peer review successful consist of the following:

• A professional review that looks at the submitted material from the perspective of assessing the concept as if it could work.
• The reviewer may agree or disagree with the submitted material.
• This is not an argument. Consider that you both want to see the author succeed in this endeavor.
• Proofread for grammar, spelling, and format.
• Does the content support the topic and research question or hypothesis?
• Assertions made by the reviewer must be accompanied by an appropriate citation reference (or references).

The peer review process is intended to mirror constructive feedback you will be expected to provide and respond to in the real world to refine a project or identify new unexplored options. Please perform each review with an open mind as a professional and with consideration of how you state your questions or comments. Keep in mind the purpose of this assignment is to help refine and improve your peers' literature reviews while gaining peer review experience.

In the threaded replies below, you will find the Research Paper: Literature Review submissions. In this module, you will select two papers to review from these threaded replies. When your peer reviews are complete, post them inside their original threaded reply.

Note: This activity is due on the last day of this module week.