Fill This Form To Receive Instant Help
Homework answers / question archive / This is a four part assignment
This is a four part assignment.
Part 1: (1 pages)
Although this class focuses on ethics in the arena of criminal justice, ethical dilemmas arise in all facets of our lives. In response to this Discussion, tell us about an ethical dilemma that you've encountered in your personal or professional life, and how you dealt with it.
This week's reading discusses the utilitarian approach to ethics. The primary example employed is using torture to gain information to combat terrorism.
Give us a different example of the utilitarian approach to ethics (it may or may not be related to criminal justice) and explain why you do or do not agree with it under those circumstances. In order to get full credit, you must post at least one response to a classmate's posting.
The example I believe that is appropriate for this question would be the extrajudicial executions in the Philippines. Instead of identifying a myriad of national issues to aggressively address, President Rodrigo Duterte, current president of the Philippines has chosen to stomp out the illicit drug trade in his country. Duterte has gone on record as stating “We will not stop until the last drug lord . . . and the last pusher have surrendered or are put either behind bars or below the ground, if they so wish.” Iyengar, R., Cruz, K. D., & Royandoyan, R. (2016) . Since being sworn into office approximately four months ago, over 3000 "alleged" drug dealers have been executed, with 41% of this number being executed without a trial in the month of September alone. With disturbing numbers like that, 700,000 other self identified users or dealers have summarily surrendered to the Filipino Police.
With all of that being stated or known just off of one issue, one would certainly ask "what are next four top issues affecting the Philippines?" Well civil rights abuse, poverty, corruption, and sovereignty issues with China are all issues Duterte and his administration should be focusing on in addition to rampant drug dealing.
Do I agree with the way the drug dealing issues are being dealt with? The answer is emphatically no! One must identify the root problem, killing the "diseased tree" and not just picking off the "rotten fruit". What I mean by this is President Duterte is plucking the rotten fruit from the diseased tree called illicit drugs. Instead, Duterte should destroy the source, apprehend the alleged drug dealers/lords, trying and subsequently convict them, and if so execute them. There is too much of the process that is being circumvented just to get to the desired result. The illicit drug problem is not being addressed from the point of view regarding the drug user. The Ulitarian approach to this problem is preventing issue in its entirety to be address. Create drug treatment centers, drug education, and more importantly stricter anti-drug laws.
References
Iyengar, R., Cruz, K. D., & Royandoyan, R. (2016). The Killing Season Inside Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte's War on Drugs. Time, 188(14), 46.