Trusted by Students Everywhere
Why Choose Us?
0% AI Guarantee

Human-written only.

24/7 Support

Anytime, anywhere.

Plagiarism Free

100% Original.

Expert Tutors

Masters & PhDs.

100% Confidential

Your privacy matters.

On-Time Delivery

Never miss a deadline.

Muthusamy Curry Mills (MCM) is considering the purchase of a new milling equipment to replace an existing one that has a book value of $3,000 and can be sold for $1,500

Finance Aug 07, 2020

Muthusamy Curry Mills (MCM) is considering the purchase of a new milling equipment to replace an existing one that has a book value of $3,000 and can be sold for $1,500. The old machine is being depreciated on a straight-line basis and its estimated salvage value 3 years from now is zero. The new machine will reduce costs (before taxes) by $7,000 per year.  It has a 3-year life; with an installed cost of $14,000; and it can be sold for an expected $2,000 at the end of the third year. The new machine would be depreciated over its 3-year life using the MACRS method. The applicable depreciation rates are as follows:

Year 1:  33%

Year 2:  45%

Year 3:  15%

Year 4:    7%

Assume a 40% tax rate and a cost of capital of 16%.

a. What is the initial investment associated with the replacement of the old milling equipment by the new one ?

b. How much is the incremental operating cash flows associated with the proposed replacement in Year 1,2,3

c. How much is the terminal cash flow ?

d. How much is the NPV and IRR of the replacement project ?

f. Should MCM replace the old milling equipment with the new one?

Expert Solution

Part (a)

Existing machine has a book value of $3,000 and can be sold for $1,500.

Loss on sale, L = Book value - sale value = 3,000 - 1,500 = $ 1,500

Tax rate = T = 40%

Tax credit = L x T = 1,500 x 40% = $ 600

Hence, post tax sale value = Sale value + tax credit = 1,500 + 600 = $ 2,100

Hence, the initial investment associated with the replacement of the old milling equipment by the new one = Cost of new machine - post tax sale value of old machine = 14,000 - 2,100 = $ 11,900

Part (b)

Please see the table below. All financials are in $. Please see the second column to understand the mathematics. The last row colored in yellow contains your answer.

Year, n Linkage 0 1 2 3
Installed cost A 14,000.00      
Depreciation rate b   33% 45% 15%
           
Cost saving C            7,000.00       7,000.00        7,000.00
[-] Depreciation D = A x b            4,620.00       6,300.00        2,100.00
EBIT E = C - D            2,380.00          700.00        4,900.00
[-] Taxes F = 40% x E                952.00          280.00        1,960.00
NOPAT G = E - F            1,428.00          420.00        2,940.00
Incremental Operating cash flows G + D            6,048.00       6,720.00        5,040.00

Part (c)

Remaining book value at the end of year 3 = Undepreciated value = Installed cost x depreciation rate for year 4 = 14,000 x 7% = $ 980

Sale value = $ 2,000

Gain on sale = 2,000 - 980 = 1,020

Tax on gain = 40% x 1,020 = 408

Hence, post tax sale value of new machine = 2,000 - 408 = $ 1,592

Hence, the terminal cash flow = post tax sale value of new machine - post tax potential sale value of old machine = 1,592 - 0 = 1,592

Part (d)

Please see the table below. All financials are in $. Please see the second column to understand the mathematics. The last row colored in yellow contains your answer. Adjacent cell in blue shows the excel formula used to get the answer.

 

Part (e)

Yes, MCM replace the old milling equipment with the new one since

  • NPV of the replacement project is positive and
  • IRR > cost of capital of 16%
Archived Solution
Unlocked Solution

You have full access to this solution. To save a copy with all formatting and attachments, use the button below.

Already a member? Sign In
Important Note: This solution is from our archive and has been purchased by others. Submitting it as-is may trigger plagiarism detection. Use it for reference only.

For ready-to-submit work, please order a fresh solution below.

Or get 100% fresh solution
Get Custom Quote
Secure Payment