Criteria

Exceptional (90% and above)

Thesis statement

5 points
 

Student develops a focused and sophisticated research question or thesis that enhances the scholarly discussion of questions and ideas that are important to scholars in the discipline.

Introduction

5 points
 

The writing provides an exceptional roadmap for the essay. In addition, the introduction includes meets all of the following criteria:

• The introduction contextualizes the thesis statement by referring to larger issues in the discipline.
• The introduction provides rationale for pursuing the thesis by demonstrating a research need or question.
• The introduction articulates how the paper will address the key question or issue being studied.
• The introduction refers to relevant, appropriate scholarly literature.

Argument and synthesis of knowledge

40 points
 

The argument builds logically upon the thesis with research-based, discipline-appropriate supporting facts, evidence, and/or data.

Student clearly describes major methodologies and practices of the field and implements them in creative and innovative ways.

The writing demonstrates the ability to interpret, analyze, and synthesize information to advance the argument.

Sources and Support

15 points
 

Student communicates, organizes and synthesizes complex and contradictory information from multiple sources to advance knowledge in the discipline at a professional level.

Student accurately quotes, paraphrases, and cites information in ways that are true to the original context with no errors.

Organization

10 points
 

The writing flows smoothly and logically from a well-defined thesis. There is a coherence in each sentence and paragraph that relates clearly to the controlling idea using appropriate examples. The flow of information demonstrates logical reasoning without jumps or shifts. The writing contains a thorough introduction, body sections, conclusion, and smooth transitions.

Style

10 points
 

The writing engages the reader through an original prose style appropriate to the subject. Language is precise and uses terminology appropriate to the discipline. All sentences are solid and reflect mature writing. Variety in sentence structure contributes to the logical flow and enhances readability.  Active voice and passive voice are used appropriately for the subject matter.

Grammar and Mechanics

10 points
 

The writing is free of proofreading errors. The writing contains sentences that are always complete and grammatically correct, and free of confusion and ambiguity.

Formating

5 points
 

Student provides a high-caliber, correctly formatted assignment in the assigned citation style. All citations in the text and in the references are accurately cited in the appropriate style.

Overall Score

Level 4
31 or more