Homework answers / question archive / For each of the following arguments, identify which fallacies are present and explain how you would craft a rebuttal against the argument

For each of the following arguments, identify which fallacies are present and explain how you would craft a rebuttal against the argument

Writing

Share With

For each of the following arguments, identify which fallacies are present and explain how you would craft a rebuttal against the argument. Include 2-3 key arguments you would make in response.

---

1-

"Airline pilots perform a task in which a single error can spell disaster, much like physicians. Pilots, much like doctors, must acquire knowledge that is constantly changing. Pilots, however, must requalify periodically to keep their licenses. Surely, requiring such requalification of doctors is just as important."

Identify any logical fallacies which are present, then offer key points for rebuttal.

----

2-"The Planetary Science Division of NASA says more than ten thousand large asteroids and four thousand small asteroids have been detected in the observable solar system. More than one thousand of these objects are each a kilometer in diameter, enough to destroy human life on earth. While a few asteroids in our vicinity may not pose much of a threat, the laws of probability clearly suggest that thousands do. It’s time we took seriously the threat posed to our safety by such enormous numbers of potentially deadly asteroids."

Identify any logical fallacies which are present, then offer key points for rebuttal.

----

3-"Representative Baker's opinion on nuclear power should not be heeded. Of course, he wants us to build a new power plant. After all, he's a far-left, tax-and-spend liberal."

Identify any logical fallacies which are present, then offer key points for rebuttal.