Fill This Form To Receive Instant Help

Help in Homework
trustpilot ratings
google ratings


Homework answers / question archive / You are the judge

You are the judge

Law

You are the judge. Alex is suing Tony claiming that while Tony was drunk he negligently drove his car into Tony's parked car and completely destroyed Alex's car. Alex complaint states there are 3 witnesses who saw Tony have at least 8 drinks less than an hour before the damage was done. Tony's answer denied causing the damage and denied being in the bar.

Tony's lawyer moves for summary judgment. He proves that Alex had sold the car three weeks prior to the accident.

Alex lawyer opposes summary judgment. He has security tapes showing Tony was in the bar drinking 30 minutes before the accident. He also has a signed statement from a neighbor who saw Tony hit Alex's car.

HOW WOULD YOU RULE ON THE MOTION?

pur-new-sol

Purchase A New Answer

Custom new solution created by our subject matter experts

GET A QUOTE

Answer Preview

Answer:

From the above statement as a judge i understand the whole situation what had happened. It seems that the Tony is telling a lie and is denied for causing the dame and for escaping himself and it is clear that his layer is also telling lie and he too present the wrong evidence of the Alex's car being in the bar. Because he didn't have any solid evidence about it.

On the other side Alex's lawyer proved with the help of security tapes showing Tony was in the bar drinking 30 minutes before the accident and has also a neighbor witness persons who give witnesses that the Tony hits the Alex's car.

Now it is clear that tony is telling a lie that he doesn't hit the Alex's car and his lawyer is alo telling a lie and present the false report and showed that Alex has sold the car before 3 months ago.

The Tony will be punished under law as per the rules of the constitution of the country and has to pay his charges of hitting the Alex's car.