Homework answers / question archive / Kant offers an example of an honest shopkeeper who refuses to cheat his customers

Kant offers an example of an honest shopkeeper who refuses to cheat his customers

Law

Share With

Kant offers an example of an honest shopkeeper who refuses to cheat his customers. Kant imagines one motive that the shopkeeper might have: a worry that if he is dishonest, word will get out and he will lose business. Why does Kant discuss this example?

a) He wants to argue that honesty is the best policy, because if the shopkeeper does what is right, he is also likely to thrive as a businessperson.

b) He wants to demonstrate that an honest action can sometimes lack moral worth if it is done from the wrong motive.

c) He wants to show us that there are many motives that have moral worth, and that the honest shopkeeper deserves our praise.

d) He wants to show that if everyone acted the way that the shopkeeper does, no one would be able to conduct business anymore. Therefore, the shopkeeper's actions violate the categorical imperative.

e) He wants us to see the inherent moral dilemma faced by those who run a business.