Homework answers / question archive / 1) Descartes gives the example of non-cooperation to illustrate his argument for mind-body dualism

1) Descartes gives the example of non-cooperation to illustrate his argument for mind-body dualism

Philosophy

Share With

1) Descartes gives the example of non-cooperation to illustrate his argument for mind-body dualism. Give your own example (not one found in the book) to illustrate when you or someone else experiences this non-cooperation. Finally, explain how your example may be interpreted by the opposing metaphysical materialist (someone who believes there is no mind-body division; we are only physical systems). 

2) Watch the video labeled "Out of Body Experience". The dualist's explanation for what happened to Al Sullivan is clear. However, how might a materialist explain Al Sullivan's experience? Be sure to address the particulars, like his ability to know the surgeon's unique arm movements even though he was anesthetized, his eyes were taped shut, and he was behind a sheet.